Thread by kanekoa.substack.com
Thread
1/ THREAD🚨 #TwitterFiles
@elonmusk slams CISA censorship network as 'propaganda platform.'
This DHS-backed censorship consortium used 120 analysts to censor millions of social media posts on elections and covid-19.
kanekoa.substack.com/p/elon-musk-slams-cisa-censorship-network
@elonmusk slams CISA censorship network as 'propaganda platform.'
This DHS-backed censorship consortium used 120 analysts to censor millions of social media posts on elections and covid-19.
kanekoa.substack.com/p/elon-musk-slams-cisa-censorship-network
2/ The DHS outsourced censorship to the Election Integrity Partnership (EIP), comprised of four organizations: Stanford Internet Observatory, the University of Washington’s Center for an Informed Public, Atlantic Council’s Digital Forensic Research Lab, and Graphika. 
3/ On the 2020 election:
•120 analysts monitored 15 tech platforms
•22 Million tweets labeled “misinformation”
•Entire “misinformation narratives” targeted for platform-wide throttling
The EIP claimed every "repeat spreader of election misinformation" was on the right.
•120 analysts monitored 15 tech platforms
•22 Million tweets labeled “misinformation”
•Entire “misinformation narratives” targeted for platform-wide throttling
The EIP claimed every "repeat spreader of election misinformation" was on the right.
4/ This Orwellian speech control network also flagged popular populist-right YouTube channels, including @scrowder, @BlazeTV, @JudicialWatch, and even the @GOP War Room, as “mis- and disinformation” spreaders. 
5/ The @FFO_Freedom report comprehensively details the US government’s role in outsourcing censorship to this public-private network.
Founder @MikeBenzCyber extensively documented the individuals involved and the flow of taxpayer funds ($40M) to domestic censorship.
Founder @MikeBenzCyber extensively documented the individuals involved and the flow of taxpayer funds ($40M) to domestic censorship.
6/ The DHS quietly corrupted CISA's mission when it designated domestic disinformation as cyber attacks on "critical cognitive infrastructure."
www.foundationforfreedomonline.com/11-9-22.html
@FFO_Freedom @MikeBenzCyber
www.foundationforfreedomonline.com/11-9-22.html
@FFO_Freedom @MikeBenzCyber
7/ But CISA had a First Amendment problem. The US government cannot sandblast millions of voters off the Internet because of their speech about elections.
CISA needed private sector partners to do dirty work. And that's where EIP stepped in:
@FFO_Freedom @MikeBenzCyber
CISA needed private sector partners to do dirty work. And that's where EIP stepped in:
@FFO_Freedom @MikeBenzCyber
8/ CISA "lacked the funding and the legal authorizations" to do grand-scale censorship and get away with it. So CISA partnered with EIP, who "filled the gap of the things the government could not do themselves."
@FFO_Freedom @MikeBenzCyber
@FFO_Freedom @MikeBenzCyber
9/ So, who are these unelected bureaucrats who get to play judge, jury, and executioner and control the thoughts of millions of Americans?
“The main character in the CISA side of this story is its then-director, Chris Krebs.”
www.foundationforfreedomonline.com/11-9-22.html
@FFO_Freedom @MikeBenzCyber
“The main character in the CISA side of this story is its then-director, Chris Krebs.”
www.foundationforfreedomonline.com/11-9-22.html
@FFO_Freedom @MikeBenzCyber
10/ Chris Krebs political bias and his affinity for domestic censorship:
•Called Trump a national security threat
•Pleased with #BidenLaptop censorship
•Passionately censored covid-19 and elections
•Wanted lawyers and doctors disbarred
•Wanted conservative media bankrupted
•Called Trump a national security threat
•Pleased with #BidenLaptop censorship
•Passionately censored covid-19 and elections
•Wanted lawyers and doctors disbarred
•Wanted conservative media bankrupted
11/ Alex Stamos, a former Facebook exec, is the founder of the EIP censorship network and Krebs' business partner.
Stamos is a member of the CFR, a member of the Aspen Institute, the director of the Stanford Internet Observatory, and he loves censoring his political opponents.
Stamos is a member of the CFR, a member of the Aspen Institute, the director of the Stanford Internet Observatory, and he loves censoring his political opponents.
12/ In Jan. 2021, Alex Stamos compared “over half of the Republicans in Congress” to ISIS.
He called on Verizon, AT&T, and Comcast to block OANN and Newsmax and said:
“We have to turn down the capability of these conservative influencers to reach these huge audiences.”
He called on Verizon, AT&T, and Comcast to block OANN and Newsmax and said:
“We have to turn down the capability of these conservative influencers to reach these huge audiences.”
13/ Kate Starbird is the head of the University of Washington’s Center for an Informed Public director and CISA’s “disinformation” advisor subcommittee.
US government grants have funded her work on domestic censorship since 2013.
US government grants have funded her work on domestic censorship since 2013.
14/ The EIP's Starbird used advanced monitoring AI to map out entire networks of people who spread a narrative.
This allowed the EIP to stalk every chain in what they deemed a "false narrative" and to systematically censor entire belief systems at scale:
@FFO_Freedom
This allowed the EIP to stalk every chain in what they deemed a "false narrative" and to systematically censor entire belief systems at scale:
@FFO_Freedom
15/ In October 2018, Starbird told her Facebook followers to vote Democrat to hold Trump responsible for "corruption and collusion" and his "racist, anti-LGBT agenda."
Starbird claimed Trump's “nationalism” didn’t stand for “patriotism” but instead stood for “white supremacy."
Starbird claimed Trump's “nationalism” didn’t stand for “patriotism” but instead stood for “white supremacy."
16/ Kate Starbird heads CISA's disinformation advisory panel with Vijaya Gadde, the recently fired top lawyer at Twitter, who famously banned the former President and opposed @elonmusk proposal to roll back Twitter censorship policies. 
17/ Graham Brookie is the figure who led the Atlantic Council’s Digital Forensic Research Lab and a previous Obama White House National Security Council member.
The Atlantic Council is a NATO think-tank with seven living CIA directors as members.
The Atlantic Council is a NATO think-tank with seven living CIA directors as members.
18/ Brookie, a government-funded disinformation expert, dedicated much of his time during President Trump’s years in the White House to promoting the false narrative that the President of the United States was a Russian agent controlled by Vladimir Putin. 
19/ In Oct. 2020, Brookie would call the #BidenLaptop “laundered unverified misinfo.”
When DNI John Ratcliffe stated that the laptop was legitimate, Brookie publicly condemned Ratcliffe’s “credibility” and accused him of “politicizing intel.”
When DNI John Ratcliffe stated that the laptop was legitimate, Brookie publicly condemned Ratcliffe’s “credibility” and accused him of “politicizing intel.”
20/ Incredibly, the Atlantic Council's disinfo lab tasked by the DHS to censor the 2020 election tweeted its director's disdain for the President days before the election.
"Trump is hands down the most significant accelerant and amplifier for disinformation in the election."
"Trump is hands down the most significant accelerant and amplifier for disinformation in the election."
21/ Ben Nimmo, a Facebook exec, leads the censorship role at Graphika and is a Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council’s DFR Lab.
He was a NATO press officer and was briefly listed as a senior fellow at the UK Institute for Statecraft.
He was a NATO press officer and was briefly listed as a senior fellow at the UK Institute for Statecraft.
22/ “Donald Trump is right that someone is trying to rig the US election, but it is not Hillary Clinton: it is the Kremlin, and Trump is an accomplice, whether or not he realizes it,” Nimmo lamented in 2016.
The Pentagon awarded Graphika $5 million in 2021 for more censorship.
The Pentagon awarded Graphika $5 million in 2021 for more censorship.
23/ In June 2019, at an Atlantic Council conference, Nimmo trained journalists on how to spot “disinformation” in Trump tweets and Brexit ads.
Senior journalists were encouraged to hold up placards reading “Bullsh*t” to Trump tweets and Brexit slogans:
@FFO_Clan
Senior journalists were encouraged to hold up placards reading “Bullsh*t” to Trump tweets and Brexit slogans:
@FFO_Clan
24/ The EIP defined "delegitimization" as speech that “casts doubt” on the election process or outcome.
This accounted for 72% of the censorship tickets and targeted over 99% of the post throttled by narrative, focusing on voting machines and vote-by-mail.
@MikeBenzCyber
This accounted for 72% of the censorship tickets and targeted over 99% of the post throttled by narrative, focusing on voting machines and vote-by-mail.
@MikeBenzCyber
25/ In effect, the left was allowed to discuss the vulnerabilities of voting machines after the 2016 election, and the right was banned from social media platforms for discussing those very same vulnerabilities after the 2020 election.
26/ The EIP collaborated with its Big Tech partners to systematically censor any delegitimization of vote-by-mail as disinformation.
In effect, they sided with the left and pre-banned criticism of vote-by-mail at the narrative level five months before the 2020 election.
In effect, they sided with the left and pre-banned criticism of vote-by-mail at the narrative level five months before the 2020 election.
27/ The political establishment and the left used the covid-19 crisis to push for nationwide mail-in voting, which increased the number of ballots cast by mail from 28.8 million in 2016 to 66.4 million in 2020, a massive 131% increase. 
28/ The percentage of Democrats voting by mail rose from 26% in 2016 to 60% in 2020, while Republican voters only saw a rise from 21% to 32%.
In short, the extra 37 million ballots cast by mail during the 2020 election swung the election to the EIP's preferred candidate.
In short, the extra 37 million ballots cast by mail during the 2020 election swung the election to the EIP's preferred candidate.
29/ In Europe, 74% of nations ban mail-in ballots for citizens living inside their country.
Brazil, Russia, Israel, Mexico, and a host of additional developed nations have also banned mail-in voting due to security concerns.
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3666259
Brazil, Russia, Israel, Mexico, and a host of additional developed nations have also banned mail-in voting due to security concerns.
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3666259
30/ In 2012, the NYT wrote, "all the evidence of stolen elections involves absentee ballots."
In 2016, Slate wrote, "the only voting fraud schemes with the potential to actually swing elections involved mail-in ballots."
www.nytimes.com/2012/10/07/us/politics/as-more-vote-by-mail-faulty-ballots-could-impact-elections.htm...
slate.com/news-and-politics/2016/09/voter-fraud-exists-through-absentee-ballots-but-republicans-wont-...
In 2016, Slate wrote, "the only voting fraud schemes with the potential to actually swing elections involved mail-in ballots."
www.nytimes.com/2012/10/07/us/politics/as-more-vote-by-mail-faulty-ballots-could-impact-elections.htm...
slate.com/news-and-politics/2016/09/voter-fraud-exists-through-absentee-ballots-but-republicans-wont-...
31/ Regardless of your opinion on voting machines or mail-in voting, it’s clear that this public-private censorship network conspired with big tech & big government to censor one side of the discussion.
In Feb. 2021, the EIP expanded its focus to censor covid-19 disinformation.
In Feb. 2021, the EIP expanded its focus to censor covid-19 disinformation.
32/ The DHS-backed censorship network launched the Virality Project, a collaboration between the EIP and the National Conference on Citizenship’s Algorithmic Transparency Institute, New York University’s Center for Social Media and Politics, and Tandon School of Engineering. 
33/ The censorship consortium monitored “keyword-based queries and cluster-based community lists of key public figures and influencers” on all of the Big Tech platforms and mass-censored entire narratives that questioned the safety, efficacy, and necessity of the mRNA vaccines. 
34/ Maddie de Garay, a 12-year-old girl in the Pfizer vaccine trial, went from healthy to paralyzed 12 hours after her second dose.
Pfizer labeled it "abdominal pain."
The VP said, "The claim that the daughter was harmed by the vaccine has not been proven."
Pfizer labeled it "abdominal pain."
The VP said, "The claim that the daughter was harmed by the vaccine has not been proven."
35/ The Virality Project:
“The idea that natural immunity from infection is superior to immunity from vaccination became a political talking point raised repeatedly by right-leaning political influencers, despite inconclusive scientific evidence.”
stacks.stanford.edu/file/druid:mx395xj8490/Virality_project_final_report.pdf
“The idea that natural immunity from infection is superior to immunity from vaccination became a political talking point raised repeatedly by right-leaning political influencers, despite inconclusive scientific evidence.”
stacks.stanford.edu/file/druid:mx395xj8490/Virality_project_final_report.pdf
36/ The DHS-censorship network claims that there are no warning signs in regard to the safety of these mRNA vaccines in VAERS, the UK’s Yellow Card reporting site, EudraVigilance (used in the European Economic Area), and the World Health Organization’s VigiAccess. 
37/ This authoritarian censorship network that operates in a constellation of NATO, DHS, and State Department-funded NGOs cannot be allowed to censor inconvenient truths, facts, & narratives under the guise of protecting the public from "misinformation."
kanekoa.substack.com/p/elon-musk-slams-cisa-censorship-network
kanekoa.substack.com/p/elon-musk-slams-cisa-censorship-network
38/ Earlier this month, the head of the EIP, @alexstamos, asked @elonmusk for “transparency” regarding the Tesla CEO tweeting, “the rules were enforced against the right, but not against the left.”
Musk responded to the CISA censorship czar, “You operate a propaganda platform.”
Musk responded to the CISA censorship czar, “You operate a propaganda platform.”
Mentions
See All
Elon Musk @elonmusk
·
Dec 30, 2022
Interesting thread
Elon Musk @elonmusk
·
Jan 17, 2023
Interesting thread
Scott Adams @ScottAdamsSays
·
Jan 17, 2023
Amazing thread. Recommended.